ICICI Direct vs. Paytm Money - Which is better?

Short Answer

ICICI Direct and Paytm Money are both stockbrokers with a high customer base and offer different tools and platforms for executing trades. But then ICICI Direct comes on top given its decades of experience as a full stockbroker and its reliability through its trading tools and investing tips. Paytm Money has the recognition but still has to strive harder to make a mark in the stockbrokers' world in terms of services and trading tools.

Detailed Answer

ICICI Direct - An Overview of the Full-Service Broker

ICICI Direct is a full-service stockbroker offering investment opportunities in almost all segments of the stock market. Being part of the ICICI group provides a unique 3-in-1 account where users can integrate their demat, trading, and savings account as one for seamless transactions.

Moreover, the ICICI group is one of the country's leading financial institutes, with ICICI Securities having more than 20 lakh customers in the country. They have no charges on opening a demat or trading account. Even the maintenance charges on a trading account is zero. However, with the demat account, the maintenance charge is 700 rupees per annum.

Paytm Money - An Overview of the Discount Broker

Paytm Money is an entirely different entity from Paytm, where it offers users to invest in the stock market and mutual funds. It's a discount stock broker that provides trading facilities with the NSE and BSE. Along with stocks, it offers trading in currency, derivatives, ETF's and more. The account opening charges are 300 rupees with Demat account maintenance charges at 250 rupees per annum, and opening/maintaining a trading account is free.

ICICI Direct Account Advantages

  1. Provides a reliable 3-in-1 account for faster transaction and easy handling.
  1. Easy investment in IPO, mutual funds, general insurance, and more.
  1. Engage in sell limit orders for up to 45 days.
  1. A dedicated website for customers having a low bandwidth connection.
  1. BSE and NSE trading facilities.
  1. Different account opening plans to felicitate different investing strategies.

ICICI Direct Account Disadvantages

  1. The packages offered are quite expensive. Even the brokerage fee is high and non-negotiable.
  1. Twenty-five rupees is charged for call and trade after 20 free calls per month are over.
  1. Trading in commodities isn't available, and trading in NCDEX and NCX is absent.
  1. Trading in penny stocks becomes difficult as the brokerage fee per share ranges from 0.5 – 10 rupees.
  1. Brokerage charges are capped at 35 rupees where small traders are hit adversely.

Paytm Money Account Advantages

  1. Low brokerage fee of 20 rupees.
  1. Reliable mobile trading platform.
  1. Support for more than 190+ banks.
  1. Net banking facilities.
  1. The 3-in-1 account is offered.
  1. IPO, commodity, currency, equity, derivates trading facilities.
  1. The highest margins can be availed by customers as high as 20 times the investment.

Paytm Money Account Disadvantages

  1. Regular updates to the portfolio aren't available.
  1. Recommendations offered are weak, with no real information.
  1. The customer care number is absent.

ICICI Direct vs. Paytm Money

Both the stockbrokers are great in their way. ICICI Direct might offer an integrated account with different brokerage plans and trading platforms, but Paytm Money offers extensive trading options with a larger customer base. Depending on your requirements, each one should provide assistance in your trading and investing ventures for a fruitful outcome.

Tagged With: icici direct vs paytm moneypaytm money vs icici direct
Ask Your Query for FREE, Get quick answers from our FINTRAKK community!
Discussion (0)
Related FAQs
Is Zerodha better than Paytm Money?

Yes, Zerodha is much better than Paytm money, thanks to the discrete offerings that Zerodha brings to the table. Zerodha has been in the stock brokering business for a decade whereas Paytm money was founded in 2017. The experience, knowledge, tools, and trading options provided by Zerodha are quite prominent and useful when compared to Paytm money.

Is Paytm Money better than Zerodha?

You wish to know if Paytm Money is better that Zerodha or it's the other way round. Zerodha being a leading discount broker in India has been there for overe a decade now. While Paytm Money already established in mutual fund investment arena, but a fairly new entrant in stock broking industry. So, let's compare the features and discuss few details on each of them.

Angel Broking vs. Paytm Money - Which is better?

Angel Broking and Paytm Money both these platforms are popular among traders. But if you are a beginner or if you want to switch to a new trading platform and you are considering choosing one of these two, and then you came to the right place.

Which is better Groww vs. ICICI Direct?

As online trading is getting popular every day, it is becoming even more important to choose the right trading platform. Choosing the best trading platform can give you more flexibility to trade in the various trading market.

What are Paytm Money Brokerage Charges? Stock Trading

Paytm Money, an emerging stock broker offers a Demat trading account to investors and traders at a fairly reasonable cost. In reality, nothing comes free of cost, may it be brokerage services or any other for that matter, you'll be charged one way or the other. So, let's see what all charges you have to bear while trading through this stock broker in India.

Which is the best stock broker for beginners in India?

Discount brokers have gained a lot of popularity in the past couple of years. Zerodha is currently India's largest and most trusted discount broker which is also the best option for beginners. It has all the necessary qualities required for a good broker like low commissions, low-maintenance charges, high-quality trading terminal, etc.

Is Paytm Money Safe and reliable Broker for Stock Trading & Investing?

Yes, it is completely safe to invest your money in the stock market using Paytm money App. In fact, PayTm has come up with stock broking services recently and trying to establish itself in the said field. And, to give tough fight to top existing players it has to keep its services up to the mark. Paytm Money made a big name in mutual fund investment industry and now it's time to see its performance in the stock brokers' world.

How can NRIs from the United States invest in Mutual Funds in India?

NRIs living in the United States can invest in Indian Mutual Funds, but there are some hassles that have to be overcome. You will require an NRE, NRO, or FCRN account in order to convert the foreign currency into Indian rupees, post which you can complete the KYC and begin investing in Indian Mutual Funds.

What is difference between Fixed Deposit vs Mutual Fund? Meaning

Fixed Deposit (FD) are saving tools offered by banks to deposit lump sum amount for a fixed period of time on a higher interest rate than saving accounts. Mutual funds are investment products which pool money from numerous small investors to create a fund.

What are Liquid Funds? Meaning & Details

Liquid funds, a type of mutual funds which invest in different money market instruments. The withdrawals from these funds are processed within 24 hours and that's why these are regarded as liquid assets. The fund manager gets flexibility to meet immediate redemption requests.

Your finances on track

Select Country